There is still plenty of time before the trade deadline is upon us. That said, roughly a quarter way through the season, the Edmonton Oilers have shown the kind of team that they could be. The perceived holes in the roster, summer concerns, have been re-contextualized by the events and performances so far.
Letโs take a bigger picture view of what the Oilers might look to do in the future.ย
Does right defence still need an upgrade?
Recently, a right shot defenceman has gained some traction as the most important area to upgrade.
Evan Bouchard would be a lock for a best on best team Canada roster at this time, and is full value as a Norris Trophy contender. One might argue this was the case last season, but international reputations take time to forge.ย
Behind him, Connor Murphy has the savvy and physical prowess to handle tough defensive assignments. He can skate and check against high level opponents of various shapes and sizes. Murphyโs fancy stats are not always pretty, but Murphy swabs up heavy penalty killing duties, defensive zone starts, and is hardly ever graced by the on-ice presence of Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl, and Evan Bouchard. While Ryan Shea has been a great fit, Murphy brings a lot to the pairing to help Shea as well.
Within it all, Ty Emberson has done well for himself this season. The Oilers third pairing has consistently been better off with Emberson as the right half. Granted, Emberson is well insulated with Bouchard and Murphy ahead of him, but it is undoubtedly his best stretch of hockey as an Oiler. While he has fallen out of favour come playoff time in the past, he does look to be more steady than ever.
Chances are that the quest for a right defence upgrade is based on getting more from Jake Walman. This is, perhaps, wishful thinking in an attempt to maximize the Oilers lineup on paper. Babcock has praised Shakir Mukhamadullin, to some extent stating a preference for a more physically imposing defensive presence on a third pairing. Acquiring an upgrade partner for Walman likely slots that ahead of the Shea-Murphy pairing, if only in name.ย
While thatโs one approach, it is a bit inelegant considering that Walman has had a hard time fitting into the lineup at all. The opposite thought might see the Oilers moving off Walman in a sort of hockey trade. Some teams might be desperate for skill on the left side, or a power play option. The Oilers might not get full value, but another player looking for a change of scenery might make sense.
Forwards not as much of a concern
A large portion of the thinking that a defenceman should be targeted is based on projection in the forward group. Matthew Savoie is coming off a great season. Replicating it, or even expanding on his role is a big enough ask, but doing so coming off of an injury and under a new coach adds a degree of difficulty.
Colton Dach has taken a step, which adds a lot of depth to the wings, joining Kasperi Kapanen as an effective middle six option. One might be wanting for a legitimate second line winger, especially if Savoie cannot pick up where he left off.
Jason Dickinson is living up to his billing as a checking centre. The Oilers might want for a centre who can push for overtime, anchoring a line that can house penalty killers while playing a stout game that is hard on opponents. At the same time, this centre might have to be able to support some scoring wingers like Isaac Howard, if need be. Importantly, it might be necessary a have a right handed centre, or at least a formidable faceoff option, to make the line viable from a coachโs trust standpoint.
It is a difficult hole to thread, and certainly a big ask from rookie in Owen Michaels. Michaels has had some troubles, especially by certain stats, though Babcock is quick to praise the details of his game. Perhaps experience and more beneficial linemates might help, though Michaels is completely unproven himself. His line has been fairly consistent, so some adjustments on that end might be the first attempt before a trade.
Some top flight wingers have been in the rumour mill, from Nikita Kucherov to Matvei Michkov. These would undoubtedly improve the team if the opportunity is available. The Oilers do have a volume of depth, even beyond those on the NHL roster. Adding a quality player usually makes sense, and targeting some extra juice to threaten outside the superstars is an intriguing concept. However, a couple depth adds could be a possibility, especially if a right handed faceoff specialist with penalty killing talents becomes available.ย
Goaltending no longer a woe?
Arguably, a decade-long unease is as quelled as ever for the Oilers. Devon Levi looks to be primed for the starting role, rising to the occasion so far. Levi looks strong and athletic, and has been equal parts spectacular and steady. The steadiness is key, in part because Tristan Jarry has settled in as well. The mechanism appears to be functional, as the Oilers defensive team play is being validated by these goaltending performances.ย
Things got a bit dicey with Matt Tomkins being relied upon, though the Oilers weathered the storm. Frederik Andersen returning will be key here, and it will be curious to see how Babcock juggles the trio should their health align. In all, the Oilers have done their part in allowing the goalies to play well. Levi, in particular, raises the ceiling, as the Oilers might now boast one of the deeper groups in the league.
Especially given Andersenโs injury history, trading away one of these goalies this season is a risky proposition. The Oilers seemed content to carry three goalies on the active roster heading into the season, and that should remain the expectation.
No news is good news for some of the younger goalies in the Oilers system. Samuel Jonsson, Nathaniel Day, and Eemil Vinni have all impressed early in their careers. Getting enough starts for all three might be a difficult puzzle to solve, but the momentum is assuredly positive. It is best to let these young goalies work their way up the depth chart in their own time, rather than being thrust into any relevant role for a team with legitimate championship aspirations.
Still time to improve this season
In all, it is a good thing that there is not necessarily an obvious answer to what the Oilers might look to add most. The team has a strong foundation, a concept of identity, and has been able to accumulate points with a savvy and grit on top of their skill. The ability, will, and belief to win in several ways is vital to playoff success, and the Oilers have a lot to work with across the board.
Savoie might be the biggest unknown at this point, and his form upon his return can change the trajectory of the team going forward. If Savoie is ready to arrive, driving play and generating offence as the puck dominant option on a line, the forward group is sturdy. A scorer might be the luxury addition, though a player who stabilizes the lineup and controls play might be better value for an upgrade.
The blueline comes into focus, in part because there is not as dynamic a fulcrum as Savoie is up front. The inelegance of Walmanโs fit and contract undoubtedly plays a part in thinking the unit could be better.
The Oilers might now have the trade assets to hunt for the biggest names, but their flexibility should help them find a good player at a reasonable price. Ultimately, which players are available in the first place will be the crucial point. The quality of the player, or perhaps even their fit into the lineup, will be vital to the calculus.
TOR has launched The Oil Rig Podcast!
All episodes are available on YouTube, Spotify, Apple, and more! Check it out!